Post-Tenure Review: An Alarming Case
From the Chronicle of Higher Education FroTwitter LinkedIn Show more sharing option Why U. of Florida Professors Decry ‘Chaotic’ Post-Tenure Review That Failed Nearly a Fifth of Those Evaluated By Megan Zahneis AUGUST 19, 2024 MARK HARRIS FOR THE CHRONICLE, PHOTOS FROM ALAMY AND GETTY IMAGES The striking results from the first round of Florida’s controversial state-mandated post-tenure reviews have confirmed the fears of many faculty advocates at its flagship campus, who criticized what they saw as a rushed and unfair process and top-down evaluation criteria. In interviews with The Chronicle, several scholars at peer institutions faulted the metrics as narrow and inflexible. At the University of Florida, more than a quarter of faculty members who were identified for review either didn’t measure up, resigned, or retired. The process, which took place this spring, initially identified 262 tenured faculty members to undergo post-tenure review, though 226 were ultim...